By David N. Harding, Staff Writer
Congress is now considering one of the most important pieces of election legislation in recent memory: the SAVE Act (Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act). This bill would require individuals to provide documentary proof of U.S. citizenship—such as a birth certificate, passport, or naturalization papers—before registering to vote in federal elections. It’s a reasonable, targeted measure designed to ensure that only American citizens have the right to vote in American elections.
Yet, opponents are mounting a furious campaign to stop the bill, claiming it will “disenfranchise” voters, create “barriers,” and “intimidate” minorities. These attacks aren’t just misleading—they’re designed to protect a broken system that makes it far too easy for noncitizens to slip into the electoral process. Here’s why the SAVE Act is not only justified, but absolutely necessary.
A Common-Sense Safeguard, Not Disenfranchisement
One of the most common arguments against the SAVE Act is that it could disenfranchise millions of Americans, particularly those who are low-income, elderly, or living in rural areas. But this claim doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. Numerous studies, including one published in Political Science Quarterly, show that voter ID and registration requirements do not reduce voter turnout, even among racial minorities, the elderly, or the poor (Political Science Quarterly, 2019).
In Arizona, where proof of citizenship has long been required for state and local elections, voter participation remains steady. In fact, when voters know their elections are secure, they are more likely to trust the process and participate in it. Requiring documentation for voter registration doesn’t suppress the vote—it strengthens its legitimacy.
Let’s be honest: you need identification to board a plane, cash a check, rent an apartment, or apply for government benefits. Is it really outrageous to ask voters to prove they’re citizens before voting in federal elections?
Closing a Dangerous Loophole
The biggest problem the SAVE Act addresses is a massive legal loophole. Under current federal law, states cannot require documentary proof of citizenship for those registering to vote in federal elections unless Congress explicitly authorizes it. That means even illegal immigrants and foreign nationals can register and potentially vote—and many states are powerless to stop it.
This isn’t speculation. It’s already happening. A 2017 report by the Public Interest Legal Foundation found that in Virginia alone, over 5,500 noncitizens were removed from voter rolls, and hundreds had cast ballots in previous elections (PILF Report, 2017). That’s just one state. How many more slip through the cracks elsewhere?
The left insists that this problem is “rare.” But a lack of prosecution doesn’t mean a lack of crime. As The New York Times itself reported, there’s no national system capable of detecting illegal voting with consistency or accuracy (New York Times, 2017). In other words, we simply don’t know how widespread the problem really is. The SAVE Act would close that loophole and provide a clear, enforceable standard: no proof of citizenship, no registration.
Minority Voters Overwhelmingly Support Voter Verification
The claim that the SAVE Act would “target” or “discriminate” against minorities is not just untrue—it’s insulting. It assumes that minority voters are less capable of obtaining ID or citizenship documents, an idea rooted in condescension and outdated stereotypes.
Polling proves otherwise. A 2021 Rasmussen poll found that 78% of Americans support photo ID requirements to vote, including 62% of Black voters and 78% of Hispanic voters (Rasmussen Reports, 2021). Americans of all backgrounds want to know that only citizens are determining our elections. This isn’t a partisan issue—it’s a patriotic one.
Minority communities, including legal immigrants and naturalized citizens, should be among the most vocal supporters of the SAVE Act. After all, when noncitizens are allowed to vote, it cheapens the value of citizenship and dilutes the voices of those who earned their place in this nation legally.
No, It Doesn’t Intimidate Voters
Opponents also claim that requiring documentation at registration could “intimidate” or “confuse” voters. This is a strawman argument. The SAVE Act doesn’t demand that voters bring a birth certificate to the polling booth. It requires proof of citizenship at the time of registration—a one-time check.
No American is being asked to show documents every time they vote. This is about cleaning up the voter rolls and making sure only eligible citizens are on them to begin with. The real intimidation happens when Americans show up to vote and wonder if their ballot is being canceled out by someone who shouldn’t be voting at all.
A Broken System Is More Dangerous Than Reform
Let’s not forget what we’re trying to fix. Judicial Watch’s 2020 analysis revealed that 353 counties across the United States had more registered voters than voting-age citizens, totaling more than 1.8 million “extra” registrations (Judicial Watch, 2020). These numbers aren’t just alarming—they’re a red flag that our voter registration system is deeply flawed.
We cannot afford to wait until fraud becomes widespread before we act. The SAVE Act is proactive, not punitive. It anticipates a problem already happening on the fringes and shuts the door before it becomes a national crisis.
Elections Belong to Citizens—And No One Else
At its core, the SAVE Act is about one simple, powerful idea: American elections should be decided by American citizens. Not foreign nationals. Not illegal immigrants. Not people who check a box on a form and hope no one verifies their status.
This isn’t about partisanship—it’s about principle. Citizenship confers rights and responsibilities. One of those rights is the vote. One of our responsibilities is to protect that right from corruption, manipulation, or dilution. The SAVE Act does exactly that.
If we allow elections to be decided by those who have no legal or constitutional right to vote, then we have surrendered our sovereignty. We’ve allowed the most sacred power in our republic to be compromised—not by foreign armies, but by our own negligence.
Take Action
Now is the time to stand up and demand accountability. The SAVE Act doesn’t undermine democracy—it fortifies it. Call your representatives and tell them to support the SAVE Act. Protect the vote. Protect the republic. Let the voice of the American citizen—not foreign influence—decide our nation’s future.
#SAVEAct #ElectionIntegrity #SecureOurVote #OnlyCitizensVote #protecttheballot #conservativecompass
Add comment
Comments